How many piers do you actually need?
It is common to get one quote for 8 piers and another for 20 on the same house. Both can be honest. The difference usually comes from how much of the house each company proposes to support, and how they judged the movement.
What a pier does
A pier (also called a piling) is a column pushed or drilled into the soil under the foundation until it reaches firmer ground. The house is then lifted back toward level and rests on the piers. Texas clay soils swell when wet and shrink when dry, which is why foundation movement is so common here.
Why quotes differ
- Partial vs full support. Supporting only the part that has dropped needs fewer piers. Some companies propose piers around the whole perimeter, arguing that a partial repair can shift the movement elsewhere.
- Spacing. Piers are typically set a few feet apart along the beam. Tighter spacing means more piers for the same length.
- Interior piers. Settlement in the middle of the house needs interior piers, which cost more because the floor must be opened.
- Diagnosis. If the cause is a plumbing leak or poor drainage, piers alone may not solve it.
For reference, the median foundation repair permit in Dallas that states a count was 11 piers, with half of jobs between 7 and 17 (Dallas data).
What an engineer's report settles
A structural engineer who does not sell repairs can tell you whether the movement needs repair at all, where, and with how many piers. The Texas Section of the American Society of Civil Engineers describes three levels of evaluation: a first-impressions walk-through (Level A), one that adds measured floor elevations and compares them with tolerances (Level B), and one that adds testing such as soil or plumbing tests (Level C). Ask which level you are getting.
Some repair companies include an engineer's letter in their quote. That is useful, but an engineer hired by you before you choose a company is the more independent check.
Questions to ask each company
- How many piers, where exactly (a drawing), interior or exterior?
- What pier type, and to what depth or refusal pressure?
- Is the plan based on an engineer's evaluation, and can I see it?
- What happens if more piers turn out to be needed during the job?